{"schemaVersion":"1.0","systemVersion":"1.7.0","canonicalPage":"https://howardopenos.com/provenance","positionOrigins":[{"code":"H","zh":"Howard判断","en":"Howard position","zhDefinition":"由Howard确认，并由其真实实践、历史表达或结果直接支持。AI只整理和连接，不构成观点来源。","enDefinition":"Confirmed by Howard and directly supported by his practice, historical expression or outcomes. AI organises and connects; it is not the source of the position."},{"code":"H+G","zh":"Howard判断＋通用知识","en":"Howard position + general knowledge","zhDefinition":"以Howard的目标、原则和判断为主干，用可追溯的通用知识补足应用条件、工具或尚未实践的细节。","enDefinition":"Howard's purpose, principles and judgment form the trunk; traceable general knowledge supplies application conditions, tools or details not yet practised."},{"code":"G","zh":"通用知识补充","en":"General-knowledge supplement","zhDefinition":"Howard尚未形成特定判断，但该信息对完整使用有帮助。必须标明外部来源，不得表达成Howard观点。","enDefinition":"Howard has not formed a specific position, but the information helps practical completeness. External sources are required and it must not be presented as Howard's view."},{"code":"NPP","zh":"暂无公开立场","en":"No Public Position","zhDefinition":"现有证据不足、尚未确认或不值得补充时保留空缺。AI不得为了页面完整而生成答案。","enDefinition":"Leave an explicit gap when evidence is insufficient, confirmation is absent or supplementation adds little value. AI must not generate an answer for cosmetic completeness."}],"evidenceKinds":[{"code":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","zh":"Howard历史公开表达","en":"Howard historical publication"},{"code":"FIRST_PARTY_PRACTICE","zh":"Howard第一方实践切片","en":"Howard first-party practice slice"},{"code":"EXTERNAL_PRIMARY","zh":"外部一手来源","en":"External primary source"},{"code":"EXTERNAL_SECONDARY","zh":"外部二手研究","en":"External secondary research"},{"code":"OUTCOME","zh":"结果与复盘","en":"Outcome and review"}],"provenanceRules":{"defaultRule":"No claim without a registered support path. Leave a gap rather than generate a plausible Howard position.","evolutionRule":"New work normally strengthens, narrows, challenges or applies the existing framework; it creates a new principle only when the current architecture cannot contain the change.","completenessRule":"Use traceable general knowledge for practical completeness only when labelled H+G or G. General knowledge must not silently become Howard's position.","aiRule":"AI may organise, compare, retrieve, draft and detect gaps. AI does not originate Howard positions or upgrade maturity.","sourceAccessRule":"Some historical sources require interactive access and may resist automated retrieval. Canonical pages preserve the confirmed summary, source identity and support relation; AI must not claim access to unavailable full text."},"principleSupport":[{"publicId":"PUB-P01-0001","origin":"H","evidenceIds":["EVD-P01-001","EVD-P01-002","EVD-P01-003","EVD-P01-004"],"evidenceStatus":"MULTI-YEAR-PUBLIC","gapPolicy":"Keep M4-candidate until outcome and counterexample review justify promotion."},{"publicId":"PUB-P02-0001","origin":"H","evidenceIds":["EVD-P02-001","EVD-P01-002","EVD-P02-002","EVD-P02-003"],"evidenceStatus":"MULTI-YEAR-PUBLIC","gapPolicy":"Keep M4-candidate; transaction diversity and outcome evidence remain open."},{"publicId":"PUB-P07-0001","origin":"H","evidenceIds":["EVD-P07-001","EVD-P02-001","EVD-P01-002","EVD-P07-002"],"evidenceStatus":"MULTI-YEAR-PUBLIC","gapPolicy":"Keep M4-candidate; method effectiveness still requires later outcome linkage."},{"publicId":"PUB-P10-0001","origin":"H","evidenceIds":["EVD-P10-001","EVD-P10-002","EVD-P10-003"],"evidenceStatus":"EARLY-FIRST-PARTY","gapPolicy":"Remain M3. Do not claim cross-cycle validation."}],"evidenceRecords":[{"evidenceId":"EVD-WRK-20260727-REG","kind":"FIRST_PARTY_PRACTICE","titleZh":"脱敏方法证据：专业分类、升级核验与企业最终决策的边界","titleEn":"De-identified method evidence: the boundary between professional classification, escalation and final enterprise decision","date":"2026-07-27","publicUrl":null,"supports":["WRK-20260727-REG","PUB-P04-0001","PUB-P12-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-WRK-20260727-BFC","kind":"FIRST_PARTY_PRACTICE","titleZh":"脱敏方法证据：业务流、财务流与现金流双向穿透","titleEn":"De-identified method evidence: two-way traceability across business, finance and cash","date":"2026-07-27","publicUrl":null,"supports":["WRK-20260727-BFC","PUB-P03-0001","PUB-P05-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-WRK-20260727-AI","kind":"FIRST_PARTY_PRACTICE","titleZh":"脱敏方法证据：AI原生工作流与双系统架构","titleEn":"De-identified method evidence: AI-native workflow and dual-system architecture","date":"2026-07-27","publicUrl":null,"supports":["WRK-20260727-AI","PUB-P10-0001","PUB-P11-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-EDITORIAL-001","kind":"FIRST_PARTY_PRACTICE","titleZh":"Howard关于公开界面以人类阅读为先、机器读取在后台运行的方向确认","titleEn":"Howard's direction for a human-first public interface with machine readability operating in the background","date":"2026-07-27","publicUrl":null,"supports":["PUB-HOME-0001","PUB-EXPERT-0001","PUB-KMAP-0001","PUB-ABOUT-0001","PUB-AI-ACCESS-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-DOMAIN-001","kind":"OUTCOME","titleZh":"howardopenos.com完成域名验证、网站指向与SSL启用","titleEn":"howardopenos.com completes domain verification, site routing and SSL activation","date":"2026-07-27","publicUrl":"https://howardopenos.com","supports":["PUB-HOME-0001","PUB-AI-ACCESS-0001","PUB-PROVENANCE-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"DIRECT"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-LAUNCH-001","kind":"FIRST_PARTY_PRACTICE","titleZh":"Howard关于正式公开、CC BY 4.0、身份、联系方式与产品状态的集中确认","titleEn":"Howard's consolidated confirmation of public access, CC BY 4.0, identity, contact and product status","date":"2026-07-27","publicUrl":null,"supports":["PUB-HOME-0001","PUB-ABOUT-0001","PUB-PUBLISHING-0001","PUB-AI-ACCESS-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-PROFILE-001","kind":"EXTERNAL_PRIMARY","titleZh":"侯铁成公开职业履历汇总与本人确认","titleEn":"Public professional history of Howard Hou, consolidated and confirmed","date":"2026-07-27","publicUrl":null,"supports":["PUB-ABOUT-0001","PUB-EXPERT-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-AUDIT-001","kind":"OUTCOME","titleZh":"Gate 2最终内容、来源、版本与机器索引审计","titleEn":"Gate 2 final audit of content, provenance, versions and machine indexes","date":"2026-07-26","publicUrl":null,"supports":["PUB-PROVENANCE-0001","PUB-AI-ACCESS-0001","PUB-EVOLUTION-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-GOV-001","kind":"FIRST_PARTY_PRACTICE","titleZh":"Howard关于AI生成边界、持续完善与证据支持的治理讨论","titleEn":"Howard's governance dialogue on AI boundaries, continuous improvement and evidence support","date":"2026-07-26","publicUrl":null,"supports":["PUB-PROVENANCE-0001","PUB-AI-ACCESS-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P01-001","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"股价连续涨停，真的是并购的威力？并购与市值管理（三）","titleEn":"Is a price surge really the power of M&A? M&A and market-value management III","date":"2022-06-02","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/TwU05LBZvTXPgKkEXF_9Lg","supports":["PUB-P01-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P01-002","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"案例研究心得之一，四个主义","titleEn":"Case-study reflections: four orientations","date":"2022-08-27","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/olwKYkOHVRF4tnovYuoTVA","supports":["PUB-P01-0001","PUB-P02-0001","PUB-P07-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P01-003","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"长期，价值，冗余，专业四个主义的进一步解读","titleEn":"A further reading of long term, value, redundancy and professionalism","date":"2022-12-29","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/QiCLUlTu-NEouaxE5sM9Pg","supports":["PUB-P01-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P01-004","kind":"EXTERNAL_SECONDARY","titleZh":"公众号转发：关于价值、估值、市值和价格的思考（非Howard原创）","titleEn":"Shared external article: reflections on value, valuation, market value and price (not authored by Howard)","date":"2024-04-19","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/1ND_dfE3VxP5GoVK8vr5kg","supports":["PUB-P01-0001","PUB-P03-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-AUDIT-002","kind":"OUTCOME","titleZh":"首轮历史资产深化中的作者归属纠正","titleEn":"Authorship correction from the first historical-asset deepening pass","date":"2026-07-27","publicUrl":null,"supports":["PUB-P01-0001","PUB-PROVENANCE-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P02-001","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"如何通过并购进行产业转型——东方园林案例复盘","titleEn":"Industrial transformation through M&A: a case review","date":"2022-08-19","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/XADrHdJlUacX5US8VWiGeQ","supports":["PUB-P02-0001","PUB-P07-0001","CASE-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P02-002","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"沉舟侧畔千帆过，并购转型向死生","titleEn":"M&A transformation under pressure","date":"2023-12-09","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/TkQec8E4Cl7ur1FYmtS5UQ","supports":["PUB-P02-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P02-003","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"并购的趋势：从投资判断，到系统性并购再到产业整合","titleEn":"The evolution of M&A: from investment judgment to integration","date":"2024-11-15","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/ensFr1RKSHFX4zupA3ioaw","supports":["PUB-P02-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-CASE-0002","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"业绩下滑、对赌失败、股价腰斩，控股权收购的潜在风险","titleEn":"Potential risk in control acquisitions","date":"2022-05-15","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/iy6JGKXRkU-qfOzB7NSWvw","supports":["CASE-0002","PUB-P03-0001","PUB-P04-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-CASE-0003","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"深度复盘——深高速收购蓝德环保得失","titleEn":"Review of Shenzhen Expressway's acquisition of Lande Environmental","date":"2024-08-05","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/KUFXqC6stQMVylpgkmj58g","supports":["CASE-0003","PUB-P05-0001","PUB-P06-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-CASE-0004","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"可转债与资本结构：维尔利案例带来的启示与灵活操作","titleEn":"Convertible bonds and capital structure: lessons from Weile","date":"2026-03-14","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/Hf9QFQHu5Xufm4m49bcqXQ","supports":["CASE-0004","JDG-0007","PUB-P03-0001","PUB-P04-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-CASE-0005","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"ST博天（603603）债务重组启示录","titleEn":"Lessons from ST Poten's debt restructuring","date":"2022-11-26","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/gbE0M9mgGarBX9jsNHE_zA","supports":["CASE-0005","JDG-0008","PUB-P04-0001","PUB-P06-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-CASE-0006","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"16亿投资获利近百亿，一起大并购的复盘","titleEn":"Reviewing a major acquisition and its large paper return","date":"2022-09-15","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/_zFb47dAnagJYz41bPNm3Q","supports":["CASE-0006","JDG-0009","PUB-P05-0001","PUB-P07-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-CASE-0007","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"山高环能——丝血反杀终被杀","titleEn":"Shangao Environment: an interim reversal and later decline","date":"2024-07-14","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/UO7GluqpWiGv502d31upkA","supports":["CASE-0007","JDG-0010","PUB-P05-0001","PUB-P08-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-CASE-0008","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"频频破发、股价低迷，新上市的环保企业怎么了？","titleEn":"Why newly listed environmental companies traded poorly","date":"2022-05-12","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/MUKaM5iOOvxK8hXnOgZLMw","supports":["CASE-0008","JDG-0011","PUB-P01-0001","PUB-P03-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-CASE-0009","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"谈并购后整合协同那点事","titleEn":"Post-merger integration and synergy","date":"2022-06-16","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/c_cn0DuirPvC5a-WosRTcQ","supports":["CASE-0009","JDG-0012","PUB-P05-0001","PUB-P06-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P07-001","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"如何做案例研究","titleEn":"How to conduct case research","date":"2018-11-26","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/Mx4jcGriVyIf6ow4AWu6jA","supports":["PUB-P07-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P07-002","kind":"HOWARD_PUBLICATION","titleZh":"年度案例研究总结","titleEn":"Annual case-research review","date":"2023-12-23","publicUrl":"https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/2AugiwEXFkAbBDAaIH5q0Q","supports":["PUB-P07-0001"],"access":"PUBLIC","machineAccess":"INTERACTIVE_GATE"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P10-001","kind":"FIRST_PARTY_PRACTICE","titleZh":"真实项目从一次回答转向持续对象","titleEn":"Real projects move from one-off answers to maintained objects","date":"2026-07-26","publicUrl":null,"supports":["PUB-P10-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P10-002","kind":"FIRST_PARTY_PRACTICE","titleZh":"AI连接研究、判断、审阅与行动接口","titleEn":"AI connects research, judgment, review and action interfaces","date":"2026-07-26","publicUrl":null,"supports":["PUB-P10-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"},{"evidenceId":"EVD-P10-003","kind":"FIRST_PARTY_PRACTICE","titleZh":"AI实践证据尚未完成跨周期验证","titleEn":"AI practice evidence has not yet achieved cross-cycle validation","date":"2026-07-26","publicUrl":null,"supports":["PUB-P10-0001"],"access":"ABSTRACTED","machineAccess":"ABSTRACTED_ONLY"}]}